If you wander around Worcester Cathedral you are bound to
come across the interesting effigies of a Knight and his lady in the north
aisle, near the porch door. If you go
and look at the tomb, you will notice the arms of the Beauchamps – Earls of Warwick, and Beauchamps, Barons of Powick.
There has been much dispute about whether the effigies are of Sir John Beauchamp of Holt and his wife Joan, or Sir John Beauchamp of Powick and his wife Elizabeth.
Sir John Beauchamp of Holt rose rapidly in the favour of Richard II. He served in the wars in
France, and received the honour of knighthood for his service in the wars
against the Scotch. In 1377 he became Steward of the King’s household, and on
October 10th of the same year was by patent (being the first
instance of the kind) created Lord de Beauchamp, Baron of Kidderminster. However,
he did not enjoy these honours long - he was seized by the King for having
appeared in arms in London together with other Lords “for treasonable purposes” – and after confinement at Dover he was beheaded on Tower Hill aged 58.
It was said that the monks at Worcester Cathedral, being
ancient friends of his family, received his body into their Cathedral, in which
it was interred, and his tomb was erected over his grave. If you believe that
the tomb belongs to Sir John Beauchamp of Holt, you may attribute the relevance
of the swans that the couple rest
their heads on to the crest of the Atwoods of Wolverly, the last of whom John
Beauchamp of Holt was declared to be heir.
An interesting story is associated with the swans on the
effigy:
One of the Atwoods who had gone to the Crusades, had been
so long absent that his wife was about to remarry. But, before she did, her
milk-maid, guided by a dog, found a man who was emaciated, unkempt, and had
iron shackles around his limbs lying asleep on the grass in a meadow. Despite
the haggard appearance of the man, the dog seemed to know him and greeted him
as a friend. The maid fetched her mistress, and when the man greeted her, he
claimed that she was his wife. The Knight told the tale of how he has been
taken prisoner and kept in a dungeon. One night when he was praying for
deliverance an angel came and spoke words of comfort; then he lost
consciousness, and when he awoke he found himself in the meadow. The knight had
a vague memory of moving through space; but being too humble of heart to
imagine that an angel had been sent to carry him, he declared a swan had brought
him, for he had perceived feathers around him. For this reason, he took a swan
for his crest, and the dog which recognised him was carved in marble at the
feet of his effigy. 
However, many people are very cynical of this story. On
many sculpted tombs a helm of some sort was needed as a support for the Knight’s head, it could be argued that the swans
were only there as a support, not to represent the legend of the Atwood family.
The animals are also thought to have represented the Knight’s tourneying triumphs, or as recognition
of military achievements which was very common in effigies. It has also been questioned
that if Sir John Beauchamp of Holt was beheaded, why would a grand tomb be
erected in his honour? Furthermore, it has been recorded by W.M. Thomas in 1737
that in the nave there is a monumental slab minus its brass of a man of armour,
which he attributed to Sir John Beauchamp of Holt (which is now lost). This must
surely mean the tomb is more likely to represent John Beauchamp of Powick and
his wife Elizabeth.
Alice
Leonard
Bibliography:
- Hutchinson's Worcester Monuments, Oxford 1944
- Worcester Cathedral - It's monuments and their Stories - The Very Rev. W. Moore, Worcester 1925
- English Church Monuments in the Middle Ages - Nigel Saul, Oxford 2009
- Transactions of the Worcestershire Archaeological Society - Vol. 18, 2002 - Medieval Military effigies up to 1500 remaining in Worcestershire - Mark Downing
